The last dictatorship in Argentina (1976-1983) was mostly described as the final stage of a long succession of political and economic crises, whose deep expression was the extermination and torture of 30.000 leftist activists, students, and human rights defenders. Only in recent times, scholars and activists are openly speaking out about the violence against other marginalized communities, developed as part of the genocidal project of the military junta. Since 2010, different scholars are reflecting on the sexual orientation and gender identities of those victims, and some archival projects led by trans organizations are collecting testimonies and pictures that portray the particular cruelty that trans and queer people suffered in police stations, clandestine centers of detention, and the streets. As part of this claim for the recognition of the victims and reparations of their memories, scholars and activists are publicly demanding the addition of 400 trans and queer victims into the traditional number of 30.000 victims. For this reason, in many demonstrations, articles, and memorials, the number of 30.400 disappeared people was included. The new generations of Argentine human rights activists, who soon will be the first without the living experience of the Mothers and Grandmothers of Plaza de Mayo, took as part of their legacy a cipher that was the result of a very particular voice in the human rights movement in the 1980s: Rabbi Marshall Meyer.
When Rabbi Marshall Meyer (1930-1993) arrived in Argentina from the United States in 1958, many of the political conflicts that had exploded during the last dictatorship were still in their germinal phase. He was an active witness of the growing political violence during the proscription of Juan Perón, the creation of leftist organizations against the repressive military intervention, the return of Perón, the establishment of the Anti Communism Argentine Alliance, and the long succession of weak democratic governments and succession of weak democratic governments alternating with dictatorships. Before the dictatorship reached its highest development, Rabbi Marshall Meyer worked hard, reconnecting Jewish youth with their roots, creating the first Jewish summer camps in Argentina, founding the Congregation Bet El and the Latin American Rabbinical Seminary, and becoming a prominent figure among the Argentine interfaith clergy. In 1976, he felt the duty of breaking the silence about the cruel repressive violence that affected all the sectors in Argentine society, but particularly his young Jewish students, targeted as potential communist and leftist terrorists. Rabbi Marshall also broke the religious rules to support his congregation. Many times he did not observe the Shabbat or high holidays because he had to visit Jewish friends and students who were detained, tortured, and sometimes disappeared. Every day he received worried families seeking their children and grandchildren, kidnapped for the military junta. In 1980, he founded the Jewish Movement for Human Rights and advocated for Jewish and non-Jewish victims, using his influence with the Israeli and American Embassies. When, in 1983, Raul Alfonsín won the elections and established the National Commission for the Disappearance of Persons (CONADEP), he appointed Rabbi Marshall Meyer jointly with other clergy, journalists, and well-known intellectuals. A big part of his work was to collect testimonies abroad and debate publicly about the special torture applied against Jewish victims.
During his role as a member of CONADEP, he understood that Jewish, Trans and Queer victims were treated with particular cruelty. He himself suffered a particular mistreatment every time he visited Jewish detainees in the jails: although his role was similar to any other chaplain, he was never treated like the Catholic ones. Every time he was forced to take off his clothes and be examined by the soldiers, who made jokes about Nazism and Holocaust. The dictatorship did not target Jewish, trans and queer people particularly, their main targets were the leftist activists, Marxists, Peronist and unionist leaders, but when the detainees were also Jewish, trans or queer they received were subjected to additional harassment: they were humiliated constantly due their sexuality, raped anally by multiple soldiers, obligated to be naked doing “feminine” tasks like cleaning and laundry, etc. On many occasions, even straight Jewish men were raped or treated like homosexuals, because the military forces associated being Jewish with homosexuality. Jacobo Timmerman, one of the most vocal Jewish detainees, journalist and author of “Prisoner Without a Name, Cell Without a Number”, testified about the many times he was treated with derogatory insults about homosexuality. Those experiences were the foundation for the multiple statements of Rabbi Marshall Meyer about the estimated number of 400 LGBT victims who suffered a distinctive violence under the military repression. Today, the legacy of Rabbi Meyer, one of the main advocates for Jewish, trans, and queer people in the CONADEP, represents a key piece in the demand for recognition and reparation of trans and queer victims, but also a strong accusation about the role of the state in the repression of these marginalized communities.
My project links the political biography of Rabbi Meyer with the multiple stories of trans and queer activists who fought against conservatism/fascism in Argentina. In our current world, the role of religiosity and clergy are mostly associated with right-wing movements, anti-trans and anti-queer politics, and fascism in the world; hiding the multiple experiences in the past and present that linked prayer and protest. Rabbi Marshall Meyer’s experience was not an isolated one, he was the Jewish voice of the Liberation Theology and the Clergy for the Third World movement, who spread a message of social justice across the Americas. In this poster presentation, I will focus on the cipher of 400 trans and queer victims as a symbol of the huge potential behind a joint collaboration between religious and gender/sexual activisms. Around the number of 400 trans and queer victims, I will organize the main events of Rabbi Meyer’s life, as well as the significant trans and queer claims for reparations and justice. The final goal of this project is to take a look at the value of the joint actions by religious, sex, and gender communities who pray and protest together.